Book Review: Eclipse (The Twilight Saga, #3) by Stephenie Meyer
As I cracked open Eclipse, the third installment in Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight Saga, I felt a wave of nostalgia wash over me. It’s hard to believe it’s been over a decade since young love, vampires, and shape-shifters took the world by storm. Driven by my curiosity over Meyer’s interpretation of the very passionate and tumultuous Wuthering Heights, I dove in with both excitement and a hint of dread—after all, Elizabeth had already lowered my expectations significantly.
The story progresses with Bella Swan caught in an emotional whirlwind between Edward Cullen, her vampire soulmate, and Jacob Black, the fun, earthier werewolf. The narrative deepens the love triangle that readers have become all too familiar with, where Bella is ultimately faced with two very different paths: the passion of the immortal and the warmth of the earthly. The key themes of choice, love, and identity are interwoven with the complexities of growing up and figuring out where home truly lies.
Meyer continues to weave her enchanting prose, but I found myself yearning for more depth, especially concerning Bella’s character. The juxtaposition of her relationship with Edward—intense, possessive, and almost claustrophobic—with Jacob’s more familial and playful approach left me reflecting on the nature of love itself. Did I feel the stakes were high enough? Not quite. Unlike the unforgiving, tumultuous landscape of Wuthering Heights, Meyer’s world feels softer, like a "virgin daiquiri version" of genuine passionate conflict. One can almost picture Bella and Jacob slurping down their watered-down version of love at a kiddie table while the real gut-wrenching drama of true love—and loss—exists beyond their bubble.
The writing itself is filled with moments that gave me pause, such as Bella’s self-sacrificial tendencies and moments of introspection. However, these reflections often seemed lost in a haze of melodrama. Meyer’s frequent turns of phrase—like the infamous instances of characters ‘snorting’ for emphasis—while charming, felt at times like crutches to bolster drama, leaving the readers wanting for richer dialogues.
In reimagining classic love stories, one can appreciate Meyer’s ambition. Yet, I can’t help but agree with Elizabeth in that many of the nuances from Wuthering Heights were misinterpreted or oversimplified. For Bella to be compared to Catherine Earnshaw felt like an affront—there’s a fire and fierceness in Catherine that Bella seems to lack. Bella’s self-doubt and yearning to keep everyone happy resemble a mother hen more than a honey badger, which left me wishing for a more complex protagonist.
Despite my frustrations, I recognize that Eclipse has its moments. Jacob’s raw energy and connection to nature provide a refreshing contrast to Edward’s ethereal allure. The emotional stakes might not be as punishing as those faced in classics, but the heart of teenage love is beautifully illustrated for what it is: thrilling and agonizing. It’s a love story that reflects real emotions, albeit in a somewhat fantastical environment.
For those readers who enjoyed the earlier books and appreciate a love story with a supernatural twist, Eclipse is worth a read. It may not hold the deep emotional weight of Wuthering Heights, but it does invite readers to ponder the nuances of love and identity. Ultimately, it’s an experience that serves up both heartache and hope, reminding us that sometimes, in fiction, as in life, the choices we make shape who we become.
So there you have it, a mix of nostalgia, contradiction, and a touch of melodrama. If you’re a fan of love triangles and supernatural twists, or if you’re curious to see how Meyer interprets the classics, Eclipse is waiting for you to dive in—and who knows, you might just enjoy the ride!
Discover more about Eclipse (The Twilight Saga, #3) on GoodReads >>
