A Cozy Reunion with Molly the Maid in The Mystery Guest
As a book lover, I’ve often found myself drawn to characters who linger in my mind long after the last page is turned. It’s safe to say that Molly the Maid has planted herself firmly in my literary heart. Returning to her world in The Mystery Guest, the second installment of the series by Nita Prose, felt like stepping into an old friend’s kitchen, filled with comfort and familiarity. With a perfect blend of charm, wit, and mystery—albeit a gentler one than the first book—I was eager to see how Molly’s adventures would unfold.
Set four years after the events of The Maid, Molly is now the Head Maid at the opulent Regency Grand boutique hotel in New York. Our beloved character is still hyper-focused on perfection and navigating the complexities of her personal life with her beau, Juan Manuel. As the hotel gears up for a high-profile event aimed at moving past the shadows of a previous murder, a sudden and unexpected death—a world-renowned mystery author, no less—shakes up the establishment. What follows is a delightful investigation steeped more in character development than in nail-biting tension.
One of the joys of The Mystery Guest lies in its focus on character-oriented drama rather than a knotty murder mystery. Molly, with her unique worldview and heartfelt biases toward her loved ones, remains a beacon of authenticity. I loved how Prose has resisted the urge to label Molly’s social quirks, allowing her to be a fully realized person rather than a stereotype. This nuanced portrayal offers a refreshing reminder that social awkwardness can simply be part of one’s individuality, free from labels.
The writing is fast-paced, making it easy to devour this nearly 300-page book in a handful of hours. The cleverness of the title aptly reflects Molly’s own struggles with identity, particularly as the different threads of her past intertwine with her present. Prose’s flair for vocabulary enriches the narrative, providing a delightful experience that feels akin to savoring a fine meal.
The dual timelines—Molly’s childhood memories and the current mystery—work beautifully together. They don’t just serve as context; they enhance our understanding of Molly’s character and motivations, creating a multi-layered reading experience. There are moments of dark humor that enliven the narrative, often courtesy of Molly and her interactions with the delightfully quirky cast of hotel staff, which keeps things entertaining.
While I found much to enjoy in the novel, there were a couple of mixed elements. The repetitious structure in the first half occasionally felt grating, particularly in the portrayal of Lily, Molly’s timid assistant. Additionally, I found myself yearning for more depth in Molly’s relationship with Juan Manuel; as their romance appears to have settled into comfort, I wanted to see more of their dynamic play out.
That being said, my biggest disappointment was the surprise reveal at the end, which felt somewhat forced and unnecessary.
In conclusion, The Mystery Guest is a cozy mystery that focuses more on character growth and interpersonal dynamics than on the mechanics of a murder investigation. While it may not offer the twisty plot some readers might expect, its heart and charm make it highly recommendable. If you love character-driven narratives brimming with warmth and humor, you’ll find Molly’s journey both relatable and enriching.
I can’t wait to see where Molly travels next—it seems we may be checking out of the Regency Grand, and I’m eager to follow her wherever she goes. 💖✨
Rating: 4.25 stars.
Connect with me on Instagram, X/Twitter, or Facebook for more bookish musings!
Discover more about The Mystery Guest (Molly the Maid, #2) on GoodReads >>