Book Review: The House Across the Lake by Riley Sager
When I first heard about The House Across the Lake, I was immediately intrigued. A recently widowed actress, a picturesque lake house, and a story that promises suspense and intrigue—what more could a book lover want? Riley Sager, known for his twisty thrillers, has a way of catching my attention, and I couldn’t resist diving into this latest offering.
In The House Across the Lake, we meet Casey Fletcher, a woman trying to escape her tumultuous past while hiding from the prying eyes of the media. Retreating to her family’s lake house, she finds solace in a pair of binoculars and a questionable stock of liquor. Across the lake live the seemingly perfect couple, Tom and Katherine Royce. But as Casey soon discovers, their life isn’t as idyllic as it appears. The moment she saves Katherine from drowning, a fragile friendship begins, yet it swiftly spirals into a web of obsession and dark secrets when Katherine suddenly vanishes.
Throughout the book, Sager cleverly taps into themes of voyeurism, the façade of perfection, and the haunting depth of human relationships. The layering of suspense is palpable, and the way Casey’s perspective shifts from passive observer to active participant held my attention. Yet, while the setup was promising, I felt the execution fell short, with predictable turns and character actions that left me scratching my head.
Sager’s writing has noticeably matured, with a smooth flow that keeps the pages turning. However, I couldn’t shake the feeling of déjà vu as I read. The plot seemed to echo tropes I’ve encountered far too often, making the twists feel less surprising than intended. It’s like watching a movie that remixes elements of classics without bringing anything fresh to the table. The recurring mentions of "across the lake" felt excessive, and at times, I wondered if Sager had forgotten the variety that enriches storytelling.
The character dynamics were also puzzling. Casey’s interactions felt unrealistic, especially her reactions to the dangers surrounding her. There were moments that should have invoked fear or caution, yet they often resulted in a strange calmness—definitely not the behavior you’d expect in such a setting. The presence of a “hot handyman” was another familiar trope that, while entertaining, felt all too convenient.
My biggest frustration was with the twisty, supernatural ending. It felt disjointed and left me questioning if it was an attempt at adding depth. Instead, it turned the narrative on its head in a way that felt unearned. The sudden inclusion of a possessive element seemed out of place, almost like an afterthought. For someone like me who appreciates well-foreshadowed developments, it was less than satisfying.
In conclusion, while The House Across the Lake has its engaging moments and certainly won’t dull the thrifty reader’s appetite for suspense, it may not offer the depth or fresh perspective some may seek. If you enjoy thrillers that play with familiar themes and don’t mind predictable twists, this book might be just the ticket. However, for those hoping for a groundbreaking narrative, it might be best to look elsewhere.
As for me, while I found moments of enjoyment, I couldn’t help but feel that Sager has more stories to tell and perhaps should take some time to explore new territories. Here’s hoping his next book surprises us all in the best possible way!
Discover more about The House Across the Lake on GoodReads >>