A Disappointing Dive: My Thoughts on Home Is Where the Bodies Are
From the moment I first caught wind of Home Is Where the Bodies Are by Jessica Harlow, I was instantly hooked; the title promised suspense, intrigue, and a journey into the murky depths of familial ties. When the publishers rejected my request for an early copy, my reaction was akin to a bodybuilder skipping out on protein shakes—understandably sore, and perhaps a tad embarrassing! However, the creative decision to package these hard copies in VHS cassette player covers delighted me. How unique and nostalgic! I pictured myself settling in to enjoy a thrilling read, only to find that, unfortunately, the content didn’t quite match the clever packaging.
Let’s dive into the heart of this story, shall we? Harlow sets the stage with three siblings whose relationships are riddled with tension and resentment. At first, I was intrigued by their dynamics, imagining how these complex bonds would unfold against the backdrop of their shared family secrets. However, as the narrative progressed, I found the characters to be mere sketches rather than fully realized individuals. Beth, with her simmering anger and estrangement from her daughter, felt more like a caricature than a relatable character. Nicole’s erratic behavior as a recovering junkie seemed to lack the depth and nuance that could provide a compelling backstory, while Michael, the arrogant sibling, was frustratingly one-dimensional.
While I appreciate familial dramas, Home Is Where the Bodies Are felt less like a riveting mystery and more like a stage play featuring characters I couldn’t invest in. Their endless arguments—“You’re a vengeful widow,” “You’re a useless junkie,” “You’re a pretentious jerk”—became repetitive and left me wishing for some depth or revelation to come forth. The sibling squabbles could have enriched the narrative, but instead, they felt more like a dull echo.
As for the overarching mystery, I found it to be disappointingly predictable. The big reveal surrounding Emma Harper and the estranged father lacked the earth-shattering twists I was hopeful for. I was able to piece together the clues long before I reached the halfway mark, robbing me of that delightful gasp of astonishment that a great thriller can provide.
That said, not everything fell short. Nicole’s final summation of the story was a moment I appreciated, as it brought some resolution amidst the chaos. Additionally, Harlow’s sharp pacing kept my pages turning quickly, which is certainly a testament to her ability to engage readers.
In the end, my feelings about Home Is Where the Bodies Are verge on disappointment. As a devoted fan of the author, I expected a richer experience, especially given its spot on The New York Times Bestsellers List. I found the characters forgettable for the most part and left with a rather mediocre experience that merits a solid three stars.
If you’re drawn to family dramas that explore tension and past trauma, you might still find something to enjoy here. Yet, if you’re looking for a gripping mystery that keeps you on the edge of your seat, you might want to look elsewhere. I’ll continue to be on the lookout for Harlow’s future works; I have faith she’s capable of much more.
Feel free to follow me on Medium for more insights on books, movies, and everything in between!
Discover more about Home Is Where the Bodies Are on GoodReads >>