Review: Good Girl, Bad Blood (A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, #2) by Holly Jackson
There’s something irresistibly compelling about the blend of mystery, character growth, and the nuances of human relationships in Holly Jackson’s Good Girl, Bad Blood. As a fan of the first installment, I was both intrigued and a bit anxious about how Pip’s journey would continue after she decided to step away from her detective pursuits. Would she truly leave behind the world of investigation, or would fate have other plans?
Set against the backdrop of a town grappling with the anniversary of a past tragedy, the story takes us on a rollercoaster ride filled with suspense and emotional depth. Pip’s decision to pull back from her detective role felt like a protective measure, yet Jackson brilliantly crafts a scenario that pulls her back into the fray when Jamie Reynolds goes missing. This brings an urgent question to the forefront: What happened to Jamie? I found myself racing through the pages, echoing Pip’s anxiety and determination to uncover the truth.
The themes woven throughout the novel are resonate and thought-provoking. Jackson explores the destructive power of words, particularly how labeling can shape a person’s identity—a poignant reminder of the lasting impact of our words on those we care about. Pip reflects on her own journey and the effects of negative labels, making it clear that self-worth should never hinge on others’ perceptions. Lines like, “Dad said, ‘You’re a waste of space,’" hit hard, prompting reflection on the importance of supportive relationships and the challenges of overcoming toxicity.
The writing style is engaging, though I did feel the pacing flagged slightly in the beginning. After those initial pages, however, the narrative picks up speed like a runaway train, especially through the middle sections filled with plot twists and turns. The sharp dialogue and vivid descriptions create a palpable sense of urgency, making it impossible to put the book down during those intense moments.
One of my favorite quotes, “Hunches have to follow the evidence, that’s how this works,” encapsulates the essence of Pip’s investigative spirit. It’s a reminder of the delicate balance between intuition and logic—a theme that resonates deeply in both the mystery genre and real life. But while I delighted in the clever twists and character dynamics, I couldn’t help but feel that the latter part of the story fell slightly short. A subplot that emerged didn’t seem to connect as seamlessly with the main narrative, leaving me somewhat perplexed and unsatisfied.
Despite these hiccups, Good Girl, Bad Blood maintains its charm. This sequel will appeal to young adult readers drawn to mysteries and nuanced character studies—as well as those who enjoyed the first book. Jackson delves deep into the darker sides of human nature without losing the engaging spirit of coming-of-age tales.
In conclusion, if you enjoyed A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, this sequel is certainly worth picking up. It offers both thrills and thoughtful commentary, reminding us to choose our words and relationships wisely. As for me, this journey through Pip’s adventures has left a lasting impact, echoing long after I turned the final page. Whether you’re a mystery aficionado or simply looking for a gripping read, I’m confident you’ll find something valuable in this compelling installment.
Follow me on my reading journey at Instagram, YouTube, and other platforms as I explore more literary gems!
Discover more about Good Girl, Bad Blood (A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, #2… on GoodReads >>
