Everyone Is Lying to You: A Sinister Reflection on Social Media Culture
When I first heard about Jo Piazza’s Everyone Is Lying to You, the title alone sent a shiver down my spine. In an age where every scroll through Instagram reveals a carefully curated façade of happiness, I couldn’t help but wonder what truths lay hidden beneath the glamour. Piazza promises a murder mystery that does far more than entertain—it challenges our perceptions of reality in the influencer era. Intrigued by both the premise and her reputation for clever social commentary, I dove in with high hopes. I wasn’t disappointed.
At the heart of the novel are Lizzie Matthews and Rebecca “Bex” Sommers—two former college friends whose lives have taken divergent paths. Lizzie’s struggle as a magazine writer and mother hits painfully close to home. Her encounters with Bex, now an influencer known as @BarefootMamaLove, lay bare the absurdity of social media’s rainbow-filtered perfection. While Lizzie’s world feels chaotic and mundane, Bex’s seems enviable, albeit layered in hidden complexities.
As the plot accelerates with the shocking murder of Bex’s husband, Grayson, and Rebecca’s subsequent disappearance, the narrative cleverly morphs from a traditional whodunit into a broader dissection of influencer culture. Piazza illustrates the toxic environment at the MomBomb influencer conference, where jealousy and desperation bubble just beneath the surface. In Lizzie, we find an everywoman who embodies our collective yearning for authentic connections in a world that often feels artificial. As she morphs from passive observer to an active investigator, I felt her anxiety and determination clash beautifully.
What struck me most was Piazza’s sharp writing style, packed with the frenetic energy of social media itself. The pacing mirrored the addictive nature of our digital lives—fast, breathless, and alive with moments of insight. Piazza captures the insatiable need for approval, particularly when Lizzie finds herself refreshingly obsessed with her follower count during a murder investigation. It’s absurd, yet it resonates because it’s so relatable—how many of us have experienced that alluring twinge of validation from likes and shares?
Character revelation is where Everyone Is Lying to You truly shines. Rebecca’s plight, trapped in an abusive relationship while presenting a façade of domestic bliss, serves as a cautionary tale about the dark side of influencer culture. Her struggles illustrate the price we pay for algorithmic approval, a commentary that haunts the pages. Piloting the drama, Olivia Jackson—a shadowy figure manipulating the influencers—embodies the unseen profit-driven forces lurking in the background. What’s more, Piazza’s ability to draw sympathy for characters ensnared in the very systems they perpetuate showcases her narrative finesse.
However, the novel isn’t without its flaws. While the dual timeline effectively builds tension, some plot devices relied on contrived coincidences that diluted the authenticity. Additionally, the final revelations felt hurried, leaving some emotional weight unexplored. Yet, in a world where our lives are often curated narratives, perhaps this unevenness only adds to the novel’s charm.
Everyone Is Lying to You is an essential read for anyone grappling with the realities of social media. It’s a mirror reflecting our own complicities while serving as a warning about the dangers of performative connections. Jo Piazza’s novel is more than just a compelling mystery; it’s a contemporary critique that compels us to peel back the glossy layers of our digital lives.
If you’re a reader intrigued by the intersection of psychology and sociology, or simply someone who has felt the weight of curated perfection, this book will resonate deeply. It left me contemplating the intricate web of truth, performance, and authenticity we navigate in our hyperconnected age—one scroll at a time.
Discover more about Everyone Is Lying to You on GoodReads >>